The invention of electronic drums is a very important event in drumming history. The age-old problem for us drummer types is being able to practice and play drums without causing trouble and disturbing people. The big attraction of electronic drums is the solution of this problem.
It wasn’t possible for me to really practice on real drums until I had been playing for a few years and my dad helped me buy a drum set. I was probably about 13 when I first started to learn to play drums. When I was 15, my dad, through a friend of my Aunt Jane’s, bought me a second-hand drum set. My Aunt Jane had a loft in NYC’s Chinatown and she allowed me to practice my drums there. This was a game changer. The significance of these two events can not be overstated. It was crucial to my development as a drummer to have a drum set and to have a place to play it where I would not be disturbed nor would I be disturbing others.
The solution of this critical drumming problem is why the sales of electronic drums have exploded.
It’s an easy solution, and it’s easy to say “yes” to electronic drums. You have a set up that closely resembles the spatial relationship of a real drum set. They are relatively quiet. Sound-wise, playing them is similar to playing on a practice pad or set of practice pads. And finally, you have the deal closer: it actually sounds like you’re playing on real drums. The digital sounds in most of the kits are so good that you can live the fantasy of real drum set playing. When it sounds that good, it’s easy to want to play more.
These sonics may help some practice more. Practicing on a pad can get boring. Less so on the electronic kit because of the sounds. This, in general, is a good thing for drumming. Anything that stimulates more practice is a positive.
However, the electronic drum set does present some problems that are significant.
The first issue is what I call “distracted practice.” Technical practice requires focus. The electronic drum kit can distract from the required focus. When I was kid and spent a few years working on a pad, I worked very hard on my hand technique. My strokes, rolls, paradiddles, flams and the like were given priority. It made sense because there was nothing to distract me. I couldn’t hear any drum sounds and I had no drum set. What else was there to do but work on technique, reading and some rudimentary independence skills? Nothing really. So I got to focus on technique.
In my years as a teacher, I have found that technique is the big eliminator. If you don’t develop technique, you are precluded from being able to play at a high level. Most beginners don’t get that far because they don’t have the patience, focus or drive to spend the time doing the work that allows the development of a great double stroke roll or other similarly difficult technical drumming skills. Electronic drum sets make it easy to get distracted from that technical practice work.
This distraction problem as it relates to technical work and practice exists on real drums too. That’s why I frequently force myself to sit with just a pad or just a snare drum when I’m working on my hands. The same thinking will get me to sit behind a drum set without any sticks at all when I want to work on my foot technique.
Besides the “distraction problem,” there is the issue of “touch,” which, by the way, is the other big “eliminator” in drumming. It is very important to practice on a real drum set in order to really get good and in order to gain that volume control and “touch.” The relationship between the velocity and weight of a stroke and the volume and tone of a sound produced is very different on a real acoustic drum set. Those subtleties are mostly lost on the electronic drum kit.
It’s this issue that is the big problem with electronic drum sets. The trouble with electronic drums? Touch.
Here’s a story to illustrate that. It comes from a personal failure of mine, so it’s painful to tell, but the story is important and I want others to learn from it, so I will share it with you. When I was re-entering the drumming world from the land of corporate business, I landed an audition with an artist on Columbia Records. I knew this artists’ work and I really wanted to play with him.
At the time that I secured this audition, I had just left my corporate job and I did not have a dedicated place to practice on real drums. However, I had a gorgeous Roland TD-20 V-Drum kit (by the way, Roland V-Drums are my recommendation for those of you who are in the market for a set of electronic drums). So, I figured I would just practice my ass off on the Roland kit and go to the audition. What a mistake that was.
I went to the audition and in some ways I played great. I knew the songs very well and I knew what I wanted to play. And I executed that. However, I played too loud! The artist was a singer/songwriter and the vibe was a little more laid back. The volume on the drums needed to be dialed down. Not a rock vibe. More Jackson Browne than Blondie. And when I realized I was playing too loud, I didn’t really have the technical flexibility to dial it back appropriately.
The practice on the electronic drums screwed up my volume control on real drums. The relationship between the strokes and the sound produced was so significantly different that I could not get a handle on it quickly enough to make the proper changes because I’d spent so much time practicing on the electronic kit. My muscle memory was to make bigger motions because the electronic drum kit allowed that without the increase in volume that those strokes would create on real drums. I didn’t get the gig and that sucked.
But I learned a valuable lesson. I never practice on electronic drums anymore. It’s all acoustic all the time for me. And for those of you who are saying “yeah, but Mark, I don’t have a place to play real drums, I live in an apartment, so I have no choice,” get over it! Go figure it out. If you’re serious about playing drums, you will figure out a way to go somewhere and play on real drums with regularity. It’s crucial that you do.
So, do I think electronic drums have a place? Yes, I do. I think it’s a great tool for beginners to get started and get excited about drumming. It can also be useful for intermediate and advanced players seeking to work on independence or coordination ideas.
But be forewarned! Don’t get lazy and think that you can substitute electronics for the real thing. You can not.
Nuff said! Now go practice on some real drums!
- Beginner Drummers Discussion Forum - February 14, 2022
- The Gift - December 30, 2021
- The Rock Drumming Six: A Simple and Solid Drum Fill Idea - December 25, 2021
William Cunningham says
I have a set of 68 Ludwig Mother of Pearls that I bought when I was in my ending days of the Army. (The Buddy Rich set).
I’ve made a living with those drums for over 30 years..But about 7 years ago, a bought a set of Simmons SDK5s for my
recording studio…which worked out great as I only had to run one line out to the engineering mixer board. Now I’ve spent a lot of
time playing those electronics to lay down basic beats without being fancy….they cannot handle a buzz roll and other things that I
can do on acoustic drums. So that being said…electronic drums have their place in the industry, but not exclusively.
Regards William Cunningham , BillyC
Mark Feldman says
Lisa Valentino says
Mark: I enjoyed your thoughts on electronic drums. As you know, I have a set in my apartment. I use them only for working out the coordination of new material. I did have a practice room share with acoustic drums, and it was only there that I could gauge the progress of my “touch” and the overall “mix” of my sound. I often think how lucky I was as a kid to have always been able to practice on acoustic drums in my house. (and that my parents put up with that). I would also like to add that I think it is a very bad idea for beginners to only play on electronic drums. They forfeit all the areas of development that you describe in your writing. I so enjoy your articles and look forward to them.
Mark Feldman says
thank Lisa! appreciate it.
Mark- great article & beautifully written!
Couldn’t agree more on the ‘touch’ problem with edrums. To me they are not ‘drums’ at all but an entirely different musical instrument more in the class of synthesizers. Just like a synth cannot replace a piano, edrums cannot replace acoustic drums.
It has, however come to a point that one seldom sees a band play without a keyboardist/synth player, just as a great deal of bands have begun integrating edrum elements such as the octopad.
I suspect the future holds a place for edrums from rehearsal to performance to recording, especially as technology improves the touch problem and reduces/resolves the latency issue. Until that day comes, there is no substitute for that acoustic drum feel!!
Mark Feldman says
Hi Jake –
Thanks for your thoughts.
I’m not sure that electronic drums will ever be able to emulate acoustic drums, but I do believe there is a place for them.
I still agree with you that electronic drums have their place but you have told my sad drumming story. On my 16th birthday my dad said I could have a cheap car or an expensive drum set… We went drum set shopping. He had already been window shopping and talking with a salesman. My dad forcefully sold me on the Roland TD-7 (I think Roland made the best electronic drums 20 years ago, they’ve improved incredibly and still have the best electronic drums today). I was a bit disappointed but wowed at the same time. 20+ years later of drumming, my coordination and independence is good but my touch/dynamics are poop. I struggled as a music major in college and eventually changed majors because of it. It IS NOT the same to play on electronic as acoustic drums. I play at a small church where electronic drums makes the most sense but I have exclusively practiced drums on acoustic sets at home for the past few years.
Mark Feldman says
thanks, Ben! i’m sorry that this happened this way. but thanks for chiming in. you’ll be able to overcome the technical problems over time…..